ProMapRanker
🛠 Scheduled maintenance: We're performing scheduled maintenance on our scanning engine. New scans, audits and lookups are temporarily paused and will resume in approximately 12 hours. Your existing reports and dashboards remain fully available.
who is the best home warranty company

Who Is the Best Home Warranty Company in 2026

Who Is the Best Home Warranty Company in 2026
American Home Shield logo
Our #1American Home Shield

Broad combined coverage · Pricing starts at: See website

Open americanhomeshield.com
Choice Home Warranty logo
Close secondChoice Home Warranty
Visit
Liberty Home Guard logo
Also solidLiberty Home Guard
Visit

Key takeaways

  • No single company is the verified best for every home, since coverage, limits, and service fees vary by plan and state.
  • Most plans split coverage into systems, appliances, or a combined plan, with add-ons for items such as roof leaks or pools.
  • Service fees are paid per claim in addition to the monthly or annual premium, so read both numbers before you compare.
  • This article is general information only, not financial advice, and you should read the full contract for your state before buying.

Quick comparison

PickGreat forPricing starts atFree tier
American Home ShieldBroad combined coverageSee websiteNoVisit
Choice Home WarrantyBudget-friendly combined plansSee websiteNoVisit
Liberty Home GuardFlexible plans with many add-onsSee websiteNoVisit
Cinch Home ServicesAppliance-heavy homesSee websiteNoVisit
Select Home WarrantyLow-cost plans with roof leak coverSee websiteNoVisit
First American Home WarrantyStraightforward tiered plansSee websiteNoVisit
2-10 Home Buyers WarrantyBuyer and seller plans with appliance discountsSee websiteNoVisit
Old Republic Home ProtectionHomes bought through a real estate saleSee websiteNoVisit
AFC Home WarrantyLower-cost plans with flexible service feesSee websiteNoVisit

The best home warranty companies

A home warranty is a service contract, not home insurance. It usually covers repair or replacement of named home systems and appliances that break down from normal wear, subject to limits, exclusions, and a service fee per claim. Coverage varies by plan and state, and prices change often, so treat this guide as a comparison of publicly reported factors, not a verdict that one company is best for you.

Read the sample contract for your state before you buy. The contract, not the marketing page, decides what is covered, what the dollar limits are, and how long you must wait before a claim. The companies below are all live national or large regional providers in October 2026.

American Home Shield logo
#1

American Home Shield

Great for: Broad combined coverage

Open americanhomeshield.com
Pricing starts atSee website
Free tierNo
American Home Shield website
americanhomeshield.com homepage

American Home Shield is the largest name in this list, and its tiered plans are the reason many buyers start here. ShieldSilver covers systems, ShieldGold adds appliances, and ShieldPlatinum adds broader cover, so you can match the plan to the age of your home and appliances. The company also covers many items without an age limit, which matters for older homes.

The trade-off is cost. Premiums and service fees are higher than budget rivals, and per-item limits still apply, so a major HVAC replacement may only be partly covered. If you want the widest choice of plans and a large service network, American Home Shield is a strong starting point, but compare its total yearly cost, premium plus expected service fees, against cheaper plans.

Why it made the list
  • Wide plan choice including tiered system and appliance cover
  • Large contractor network
  • No age limits on many covered items
Keep in mind
  • Premiums and service fees sit at the higher end
  • Contract limits and exclusions need careful reading
Choice Home Warranty logo
#2

Choice Home Warranty

Great for: Budget-friendly combined plans

Open choicehomewarranty.com
Pricing starts atSee website
Free tierNo
Choice Home Warranty website
choicehomewarranty.com homepage

Choice Home Warranty keeps its offer simple, with a Basic plan and a Total plan that covers systems and appliances together. That simplicity helps when you are comparing quotes, because you are not sorting through a long list of tiers. Public comparison sites often place Choice near the budget end of the market, which appeals to buyers watching the monthly cost.

The catch is the dollar limit per item, which is lower than some competitors, and the usual state-by-state differences in covered items. Choice suits a buyer who wants combined cover at a lower premium and accepts tighter limits. Get a quote for your address and read the limits for HVAC and major appliances before you decide.

Why it made the list
  • Simple two-plan structure
  • Competitive pricing
  • Fast contractor contact reported in public reviews
Keep in mind
  • Per-item limits are lower than some rivals
  • Coverage details vary by state
Liberty Home Guard logo
#3

Liberty Home Guard

Great for: Flexible plans with many add-ons

Open libertyhomeguard.com
Pricing starts atSee website
Free tierNo
Liberty Home Guard website
libertyhomeguard.com homepage

Liberty Home Guard stands out for flexibility. You can buy a systems-only plan, an appliances-only plan, or a total plan, and then add cover for items such as pools, spas, or additional refrigerators. In some cases you can also choose your own technician, subject to company approval, which is unusual in this market and useful if you already trust a local contractor.

That flexibility has a cost in complexity. The base plan may not cover items you assume are included, so the quote you compare should include every add-on you need. For buyers who want to tailor cover rather than buy a fixed bundle, Liberty Home Guard is one of the most adaptable options here.

Why it made the list
  • Choice of systems-only, appliances-only, or total plans
  • Many optional add-ons
  • Option to choose your own technician in some cases
Keep in mind
  • Some add-ons are needed for cover rivals include by default
  • Service fee varies by plan
Cinch Home Services logo
#4

Cinch Home Services

Great for: Appliance-heavy homes

Open cinchhomeservices.com
Pricing starts atSee website
Free tierNo

Cinch Home Services, formerly a Sears home services brand, is a good fit if appliances are your main worry. Its plans cover kitchen and laundry appliances alongside systems on higher tiers, and public guides report a generous annual aggregate limit compared with some rivals. Claims can be filed around the clock, which helps when a refrigerator fails on a weekend.

Check the tier carefully, because systems cover is not equal across plans. A buyer who mainly wants appliance cover may find Cinch good value, while a buyer with an aging furnace and air conditioner should compare the systems tier and its limits against American Home Shield or First American before choosing.

Why it made the list
  • Appliance-focused plans
  • Annual aggregate limits reported as generous
  • 24/7 claims line
Keep in mind
  • Systems cover needs the right tier
  • Terms vary by plan and state
Select Home Warranty logo
#5

Select Home Warranty

Great for: Low-cost plans with roof leak cover

Open selecthomewarranty.com
Pricing starts atSee website
Free tierNo

Select Home Warranty is often listed among the cheapest national providers, and its headline feature is roof leak repair included on some plans rather than sold only as an add-on. That matters if your roof is older and you want leak cover without paying for a separate rider. Plans cover the usual systems and appliances, with bronze, gold, and platinum tiers.

The lower price comes with the usual budget-plan caveats. Service availability can vary by area, and per-item limits may be lower than premium plans. Select suits a buyer who wants low monthly cost plus roof leak cover, provided the limits for HVAC and appliances are acceptable after reading the contract.

Why it made the list
  • Competitive pricing
  • Roof leak repair included on some plans
  • Free roof leak cover is unusual at this price
Keep in mind
  • Smaller service network reported in some areas
  • Limits and exclusions need close reading
First American Home Warranty logo
#6

First American Home Warranty

Great for: Straightforward tiered plans

Open homewarranty.firstam.com
Pricing starts atSee website
Free tierNo

First American Home Warranty is closely tied to real estate transactions, and many buyers first meet it when a seller includes a warranty in a home sale. Its plans are tiered in a clear way, with basic, value, and premier options, and higher tiers are reported to carry no annual payout cap, which is rare and valuable for an older home with several aging systems.

Availability is the main limit, since First American does not sell in every state, and some items need optional cover. If you are buying a home and your agent offers First American, it is worth comparing its premier tier against the other plans here, especially if you expect more than one major claim in a year.

Why it made the list
  • Clear tiered plans
  • Strong real estate transaction experience
  • No annual payout cap reported on higher tiers
Keep in mind
  • Not available in every state
  • Optional cover is needed for some items
2-10 Home Buyers Warranty logo
#7

2-10 Home Buyers Warranty

Great for: Buyer and seller plans with appliance discounts

Open 2-10.com
Pricing starts atSee website
Free tierNo

2-10 Home Buyers Warranty, now owned by the same parent company as American Home Shield, offers Systems and Pinnacle plans for buyers and sellers. Both plans include an appliance discounts program that offers savings on replacement appliances from named brands, plus a service fee guarantee that refunds the fee if a request is ineligible for service. That guarantee reduces the sting of a denied claim.

The company is not available in Hawaii and Alaska, and the broader cover sits on the Pinnacle plan. For a homebuyer who wants a simple two-plan choice plus appliance replacement discounts, 2-10 is a practical option. Compare its service fee range with Choice and Select, since the fee is paid on every approved claim.

Why it made the list
  • Two clear plans
  • Appliance discount program
  • Service fee guarantee on ineligible requests
Keep in mind
  • Not available in Hawaii and Alaska
  • Some cover only on the higher plan
Old Republic Home Protection logo
#8

Old Republic Home Protection

Great for: Homes bought through a real estate sale

Open oldrepublichomeprotection.com
Pricing starts atSee website
Free tierNo

Old Republic Home Protection has served real estate transactions for decades, and its plans are built around the needs of buyers and sellers rather than direct retail buyers alone. Higher plans cover a wide list of systems and appliances, and in some cases you can work with your own contractor subject to approval. That history shows in the plan wording, which is generally clear about what is and is not covered.

Pricing sits above the cheapest plans, so Old Republic suits buyers who value a long-established provider and a wide item list over the lowest monthly premium. If you are buying through an agent, ask whether Old Republic is offered in your state and compare its limits with First American and American Home Shield.

Why it made the list
  • Long history in real estate warranties
  • Flexible contractor choice in some cases
  • Wide item cover on higher plans
Keep in mind
  • Higher price band than budget rivals
  • Service fee varies by plan
AFC Home Warranty logo
#9

AFC Home Warranty

Great for: Lower-cost plans with flexible service fees

Open afchomewarranty.com
Pricing starts atSee website
Free tierNo

AFC Home Warranty is a budget-friendly provider with several plans and a choice of service fee levels, which lets you trade a lower monthly premium for a higher fee per claim, or the reverse. Higher plans cover a long list of systems and appliances, and public comparisons often place AFC near the lower end of the price range.

As with other budget plans, the limits matter more than the headline price. Check the per-item limit for HVAC, plumbing, and electrical work, and confirm which items sit on the plan you are actually quoted. AFC suits a buyer who wants to tune the premium and service fee balance and is willing to read the tier details closely.

Why it made the list
  • Competitive starting prices
  • Choice of service fee levels
  • Many covered items on higher plans
Keep in mind
  • Per-item limits vary by plan
  • Some items need higher tiers

How we picked these

We compared plan structures, covered items, service fees, and state availability from company websites and public comparison guides published in 2026. We kept only providers that are live in October 2026 and sell nationally or across many states, and we excluded companies with no public plan detail. We did not verify any company as best, because the right plan depends on your home, your state, and the contract terms that apply to you. Prices are shown as See website because premiums vary by home, plan, and state, and quoted prices change often.

What to check before you buy a home warranty

Start with the sample contract for your state. Look for the waiting period before cover starts, the service fee per claim, the per-item dollar limits, and the exclusions for pre-existing conditions, improper maintenance, and code upgrades. Those four items decide most claim disputes, and they are easy to miss on a marketing page.

Next, add up the true yearly cost. Multiply the monthly premium by twelve, then add the service fee for each claim you might reasonably make in a year. A cheap premium with a high service fee can cost more than a pricier plan with a lower fee if you claim twice. Also check whether the company assigns its own contractor or lets you choose one, and how claims are filed outside business hours.

Finally, remember that a home warranty is not a substitute for home insurance or for an emergency fund. It covers named systems and appliances under contract limits, not storm damage, structural problems, or items you failed to maintain. If a system is already failing, most contracts will not cover it, so a pre-purchase inspection still matters.

Frequently asked questions

Who is the best home warranty company?

There is no single verified best company, because coverage, limits, and service fees vary by plan and state. American Home Shield offers the broadest plan choice, Choice and Select compete on price, and Liberty Home Guard offers the most flexible add-ons, so the best fit depends on your home and your contract.

What does a home warranty usually cover?

Most plans cover named systems such as heating, cooling, plumbing, and electrical, plus appliances such as refrigerators, ovens, dishwashers, and laundry machines. Exact items, limits, and exclusions are set by the contract for your plan and state, so read the sample contract before you buy.

How much does a home warranty cost?

Premiums vary by company, plan, home size, and state, and a service fee is usually charged per claim on top of the premium. Because quoted prices change often and depend on your address, we show prices as See website and recommend getting quotes for your home from two or three providers.

Are pre-existing conditions covered?

Usually not, or only within narrow limits set by the contract. Some companies offer limited cover for unknown pre-existing conditions, while others exclude them outright. If a system already shows signs of failure, assume it will not be covered and get it inspected before you buy.

Is a home warranty worth it for an older home?

It can be, because older systems and appliances fail more often, but limits and exclusions matter more for older homes. Compare the per-item limits for HVAC and major appliances against replacement costs, and check whether the plan has an annual payout cap before you commit.

What is the difference between a home warranty and home insurance?

Home insurance covers sudden damage such as fire, storm, or theft, subject to its own policy terms. A home warranty covers breakdowns of named systems and appliances from normal wear, subject to contract limits and a service fee per claim. Most homeowners need insurance regardless of whether they buy a warranty.

Sources

  1. https://www.americanhomeshield.com/
  2. https://www.choicehomewarranty.com/
  3. https://www.libertyhomeguard.com/
  4. https://www.cinchhomeservices.com/
  5. https://www.selecthomewarranty.com/
  6. https://homewarranty.firstam.com/
  7. https://www.2-10.com/
  8. https://www.oldrepublichomeprotection.com/
  9. https://www.afchomewarranty.com/
  10. https://money.com/best-home-warranties/

See where you really rank - block by block

ProMapRanker scans Google Maps across a grid of your service area. Simple monthly plans from $19, white-label on every plan.

Start free

Keep reading