ProMapRanker
🛠 Scheduled maintenance: We're performing scheduled maintenance on our scanning engine. New scans, audits and lookups are temporarily paused and will resume in approximately 12 hours. Your existing reports and dashboards remain fully available.
coinstar alternatives

Best Coinstar Alternatives in 2026

Best Coinstar Alternatives in 2026
American Eagle Financial Credit Union logo
Our #1American Eagle Financial Credit Union

Free member coin counting · Pricing starts at: Free

Open americaneagle.org
Visions Federal Credit Union logo
Close secondVisions Federal Credit Union
Visit
MUNA Federal Credit Union logo
Also solidMUNA Federal Credit Union
Visit

Key takeaways

  • A credit union coin counter is usually the best Coinstar replacement, since many credit unions count member coins free and deposit the total directly.
  • Rolling coins yourself and depositing them at your bank is free in most cases, but it costs time, especially for a large jar.
  • QuikTrip and Publix offer in-store coin machines, though fees and availability vary by location, so call ahead.
  • A home coin sorter like the Cassida C200 makes sense only if you handle coins often, since it still leaves you to deposit or spend them.
  • Coinstar's cash fee is high, so check the free or low-fee route first, even if it takes an extra trip.

Quick comparison

PickGreat forPricing starts atFree tier
American Eagle Financial Credit UnionFree member coin countingFreeYesVisit
Visions Federal Credit UnionFree member coin machinesFreeYesVisit
MUNA Federal Credit UnionFree member coin countingFreeYesVisit
Florida Credit UnionFree member self-service machinesFreeYesVisit
American Heritage Credit UnionFree Lucy Change machinesFreeYesVisit
Republic BankCoin counting for customersFreeYesVisit
QuikTripIn-store coin exchangeSee websiteNoVisit
PublixIn-store coin machineSee websiteNoVisit
Cassida C200Home coin counting and sortingSee websiteNoVisit

The best coinstar alternatives

These alternatives to coinstar are ways to turn loose coins into cash or a deposit without paying a large kiosk fee. Fees and machine availability vary by location, so call ahead before you carry a heavy jar anywhere. This is not financial advice; it is a comparison of coin-counting options.

American Eagle Financial Credit Union logo
#1

American Eagle Financial Credit Union

Great for: Free member coin counting

Open americaneagle.org
Pricing starts atFree
Free tierYes
American Eagle Financial Credit Union app screenshots
App Store screenshots

American Eagle Financial Credit Union is a strong first call if you live near one of its branches. Members can use coin counting machines free, with the total deposited to their account, which removes both the kiosk fee and the need to roll coins. That combination is why credit unions top most free coin lists.

The limit is geography. American Eagle serves a regional footprint, so it will not help readers far from its branches. Check the branch list and machine availability before visiting, since not every branch has a machine.

Why it made the list
  • Free counting for members
  • Deposit goes straight to an account
  • Staff help at branches
Keep in mind
  • Branch locations are regional
  • Non-member terms vary
  • Machines vary by branch
Visions Federal Credit Union logo
#2

Visions Federal Credit Union

Great for: Free member coin machines

Open visionsfcu.org
Pricing starts atFree
Free tierYes
Visions Federal Credit Union app screenshots
App Store screenshots

Visions Federal Credit Union offers free coin redemption for members, with no need to sort or roll coins first. You drop loose change into a machine, get a total, and have the funds deposited to your account. For members with a jar to clear, that is the simplest free route.

As with other credit unions, the branch network is regional, so availability depends on where you live. Non-member terms may include a fee, so confirm them if you do not hold an account. A quick call saves a wasted trip.

Why it made the list
  • Free coin redemption for members
  • No sorting or rolling needed
  • Deposit to account
Keep in mind
  • Branch footprint is regional
  • Non-members may face a fee
  • Machines vary by branch
MUNA Federal Credit Union logo
#3

MUNA Federal Credit Union

Great for: Free member coin counting

Open munafederal.com
Pricing starts atFree
Free tierYes

MUNA Federal Credit Union lets members use its coin counting machine free, then take the receipt to a teller for deposit or cash back. That process is far faster than rolling a large jar by hand, and it avoids the percentage fee charged by grocery kiosks.

Non-members pay a fee reported at 8.99 percent, so the free benefit is really a member benefit. Branches are regional, and machine use follows branch hours. If you are already a member, this is an easy win.

Why it made the list
  • Free counting for members
  • Simple receipt-to-teller process
  • Faster than rolling
Keep in mind
  • Regional branches
  • Non-members pay a fee
  • Machine hours match branch hours
Florida Credit Union logo
#4

Florida Credit Union

Great for: Free member self-service machines

Open flcu.org
Pricing starts atFree
Free tierYes

Florida Credit Union offers self-service coin machines at a list of branches, free for members, with tellers able to process loose coins at other locations. That mix of machines and teller help makes it practical even if your nearest branch lacks a machine.

The footprint is Florida only, so it suits readers in that state. Non-members are charged a fee under the credit union's schedule, so members get the clear benefit. Check the current branch machine list before you go, since it changes over time.

Why it made the list
  • Self-service machines at many branches
  • Free for members
  • Teller help elsewhere
Keep in mind
  • Florida footprint only
  • Non-members pay a fee
  • Machine list changes over time
American Heritage Credit Union logo
#5

American Heritage Credit Union

Great for: Free Lucy Change machines

Open americanheritagecu.org
Pricing starts atFree
Free tierYes

American Heritage Credit Union runs Lucy Change, its coin counting machine service, free for members at select branches. You use the machine, then deposit the total to your account, which is exactly the workflow most coin savers want.

Only select branches offer Lucy Change, so check the locations page first. The footprint is regional, centered on the Philadelphia area, so it will not help readers elsewhere. For members nearby, it is one of the cleanest free options.

Why it made the list
  • Free Lucy Change machines for members
  • Select branches offer the service
  • Deposit to account
Keep in mind
  • Regional footprint
  • Only select branches have machines
  • Non-member terms vary
Republic Bank logo
#6

Republic Bank

Great for: Coin counting for customers

Open myrepublicbank.com
Pricing starts atFree
Free tierYes

Republic Bank, serving New Jersey and Pennsylvania, is reported as offering free coin counting for customers, with some reports noting free use for non-customers as well. That makes it worth a call if you live in its area and want a bank option rather than a credit union.

Terms can vary by branch and over time, so confirm the current policy before carrying coins in. The regional footprint is the main limit. If you are outside its area, a local credit union is the closer equivalent.

Why it made the list
  • Free counting reported for customers
  • Simple branch process
  • No rolling needed
Keep in mind
  • Regional footprint in New Jersey and Pennsylvania
  • Terms vary by branch
  • Machines vary
QuikTrip logo
#7

QuikTrip

Great for: In-store coin exchange

Open quiktrip.com
Pricing starts atSee website
Free tierNo

QuikTrip convenience stores offer coin exchange at select locations, which suits people who want to turn coins into usable funds while running errands. You do not need a bank account to use a store machine, and the process is quick for a moderate amount of coins.

Availability is the catch. Only select stores offer coin exchange, and fees and limits vary by location. Call the store first, and ask about the fee and any cap before you bring a large amount. It is a convenience option, not a guaranteed free one.

Why it made the list
  • Convenient store locations
  • No bank account needed
  • Quick exchange at select stores
Keep in mind
  • Only select locations offer it
  • Fees and limits vary
  • Not a deposit option
Publix logo
#8

Publix

Great for: In-store coin machine

Open publix.com
Pricing starts atSee website
Free tierNo

Publix stores offer their own branded coin machines at the entrance, which count loose change and print a receipt you exchange for cash. For shoppers who already visit Publix, that convenience is real, and the process is simple even for a large jar.

The fee is the drawback, with reports putting it around 9 to 10 percent for cash. That is lower than some kiosk fees, but still a large cut on a big jar. If a free credit union machine is within reach, it will beat Publix on value, even if it takes an extra trip.

Why it made the list
  • Machines at many stores
  • Receipt exchanged for cash
  • Convenient while shopping
Keep in mind
  • Service fee applies
  • Payout is cash only
  • Fee varies by store
Cassida C200 logo
#9

Cassida C200

Great for: Home coin counting and sorting

Open cassidausa.com
Pricing starts atSee website
Free tierNo

Cassida C200 is a home and small-business coin counter and sorter, for people who handle coins often. It counts and sorts coins into bins, which saves the time of hand rolling and makes bank deposits neater. Small shops, landlords, and families with frequent coin income benefit most.

The machine costs money upfront, and it does not turn coins into cash by itself. You still need to deposit sorted coins or spend them, so it suits frequent handlers better than a one-time jar. For a single jar, rolling by hand or visiting a free counter is cheaper.

Why it made the list
  • Counts and sorts coins at home
  • Saves rolling time
  • Useful for frequent coin handling
Keep in mind
  • Upfront machine cost
  • Still need to deposit or spend coins
  • Needs space and power

How we picked these

We compared bank and credit union service pages, coin machine guides, and public fee reports for options that are available in the United States in October 2026. We kept only options that turn loose coins into cash or a deposit today, with a named institution, store, or product behind them. We left out banks that had removed their coin machines, since a reader cannot rely on them, and we favored free member counting over paid kiosks.

How to cash in coins without losing a large fee

A little planning keeps more of your jar in your pocket.

Call before you carry coins

Machine availability, fees, and non-member terms change by branch and store. A two-minute call confirms whether a machine is working, whether you need an account, and what fee applies. That call matters most for a large jar, where a percentage fee adds up fast.

Compare the fee against your time

Rolling coins yourself is free at most banks for customers, but it takes time, especially for pennies and nickels. For a small jar, the time cost may exceed the fee saved. For a large jar, the fee saved usually wins. Do the math on your amount before choosing.

Sort out valuable coins first

Check for older silver coins and other collectible pieces before you pour a jar into a machine. Coins from before 1965 in some denominations can be worth more than face value. A quick check with a coin guide or dealer can prevent a costly mistake.

Keep the receipt and count the total

Whether you use a machine, a teller, or a home sorter, keep the receipt and compare it with your own rough count. Machines can jam or miscount, and a receipt is your record if a total looks wrong. Count the cash or check the deposit before you leave.

Frequently asked questions

What is the best alternative to coinstar?

A credit union coin counter is usually the best alternative, since many credit unions count member coins free and deposit the total directly. If you are not a member, rolling coins and depositing them at your own bank is the next best free route. Call your institution first to confirm machine availability and terms.

Where can I cash in coins for free?

Free counting is most common at credit unions for members, and at your own bank for rolled coin deposits. Some community banks also offer free counting for customers. Large national banks have mostly removed coin machines, so do not assume your bank has one without checking.

Does QuikTrip count coins for free?

QuikTrip offers coin exchange at select locations, but fees and limits vary by store. It is a convenient option, not a guaranteed free one. Call the specific store to confirm whether it offers coin exchange and what fee applies before you visit.

Is it cheaper to roll coins myself?

Yes, rolling coins yourself is usually free for bank customers, since most banks provide wrappers at no charge. The cost is your time, especially for a large jar. For a small amount, a kiosk fee may be worth the time saved, but for a large amount, rolling usually saves more money.

How much does Coinstar charge for cash?

Coinstar's cash fee is reported at around 11.9 percent, though fees can vary by location. That means a 100 dollar jar would leave about 88 dollars after the fee. Gift card and charity options through the same machines may carry no fee, but they do not give cash.

Sources

  1. https://americaneagle.org
  2. https://visionsfcu.org
  3. https://munafederal.com
  4. https://flcu.org
  5. https://americanheritagecu.org
  6. https://myrepublicbank.com
  7. https://quiktrip.com
  8. https://publix.com
  9. https://cassidausa.com

See where you really rank - block by block

ProMapRanker scans Google Maps across a grid of your service area. Simple monthly plans from $19, white-label on every plan.

Start free

Keep reading