ProMapRanker
🛠 Scheduled maintenance: We're performing scheduled maintenance on our scanning engine. New scans, audits and lookups are temporarily paused and will resume in approximately 12 hours. Your existing reports and dashboards remain fully available.
best payroll services for hiring a nanny

Best Payroll Services for Hiring a Nanny in 2026

Best Payroll Services for Hiring a Nanny in 2026
Poppins Payroll logo
Our #1Poppins Payroll

Simple flat-rate payroll · Pricing starts at: $49 per month

Open poppinspayroll.com
HomePay by Care.com logo
Close secondHomePay by Care.com
Visit
GTM Payroll Services logo
Also solidGTM Payroll Services
Visit

Key takeaways

  • Hiring a nanny usually makes you a household employer, with federal and state tax duties that go beyond a simple paycheck.
  • Full-service providers file quarterly taxes and year-end forms for you, while do-it-yourself software calculates taxes but leaves filing to you.
  • Monthly prices in this guide range from about $39 to $75 for one employee, before extra employee fees and optional year-end charges.
  • This is general information only, not tax or legal advice, and tax and employment rules vary by state, so consult a tax professional for your situation.

Quick comparison

PickGreat forPricing starts atFree tier
Poppins PayrollSimple flat-rate payroll$49 per monthFree trialVisit
HomePay by Care.comFully managed household payroll$59 per monthNoVisit
GTM Payroll ServicesExpert support and HR options$70 per monthNoVisit
SurePayroll by PaychexAffordable automated pay runs$39 per monthNoVisit
HomeWork SolutionsPayroll plus tax supportSee websiteNoVisit
Savvy Nanny PayrollBudget-friendly payroll$39 per monthNoVisit
Nest PayrollBack taxes and ongoing payroll$42 per monthNoVisit
NannyPayDo-it-yourself tax calculation$199.95 per yearFree trialVisit

The best payroll services for hiring a nanny

A nanny payroll service should handle pay calculation, tax withholding, filings, and year-end forms, or at least make each step clear. Prices below are starting prices for one employee where published, and extra employees usually cost more.

Poppins Payroll logo
#1

Poppins Payroll

Great for: Simple flat-rate payroll

Open poppinspayroll.com
Pricing starts at$49 per month
Free tierFree trial
Poppins Payroll website
poppinspayroll.com homepage

Poppins Payroll keeps the choice simple with one plan that covers payroll processing, tax payments, quarterly filings, and year-end forms for active accounts. Families can choose weekly, biweekly, semimonthly, or monthly pay schedules, subject to state rules, and pay by direct deposit or by issuing checks themselves. That flat structure makes budgeting easy, since the monthly figure does not change with tiers.

The trade-off is less hand-holding for complex cases. Families who want a named account manager or bundled HR advice may prefer a higher-tier provider, even at a higher price. For most single-nanny households, though, Poppins offers a clear balance of price and full filing coverage.

Why it made the list
  • One flat monthly price
  • Year-end forms included for active accounts
  • Specialists in household payroll
Keep in mind
  • No separate premium tier for families who want a dedicated manager
  • Add-on fees can apply for special filings
HomePay by Care.com logo
#2

HomePay by Care.com

Great for: Fully managed household payroll

Open care.com
Pricing starts at$59 per month
Free tierNo
HomePay by Care.com website
care.com homepage

HomePay, from Care.com, is built around taking household tax work off your plate. It handles payroll, tax calculations, and filings, and it can help with employer account setup and new-hire reporting. Families who dread tax forms often value that full-service approach, since a missed filing can cost far more than the monthly fee.

The cost is the main drawback. Essentials starts at $59 per month, and the Plus plan costs more, with year-end forms adding a fee on some plans. If your case is simple and you are comfortable with a modern self-serve dashboard, a cheaper provider may cover the same filings. HomePay fits families who want the work done for them.

Why it made the list
  • Files quarterly taxes and year-end documents
  • Long household tax history
  • Care.com connection
Keep in mind
  • Higher price than budget options
  • Year-end forms cost extra on some plans
  • Interface feels dated to some users
GTM Payroll Services logo
#3

GTM Payroll Services

Great for: Expert support and HR options

Open gtm.com
Pricing starts at$70 per month
Free tierNo

GTM Payroll Services has focused on household employment for many years, and its support team understands nanny tax rules across states. Its entry plan covers employer setup, new-hire reporting, automated payroll, and tax filings, with audit support included. Higher tiers add HR support, benefits help, and a dedicated account team for families with larger household staffs.

Families should read the fee details before signing. GTM charges a setup fee, and year-end reporting can be an optional extra on some plans, so the monthly figure is not the whole cost. Even so, families with complex schedules, nanny shares, or benefits questions often find the expert support worth the premium.

Why it made the list
  • Household payroll specialists
  • Unlimited audit support on some plans
  • HR and benefits options at higher tiers
Keep in mind
  • Higher starting price
  • Setup fee applies
  • Higher tiers require longer terms in some cases
SurePayroll by Paychex logo
#4

SurePayroll by Paychex

Great for: Affordable automated pay runs

Open surepayroll.com
Pricing starts at$39 per month
Free tierNo

SurePayroll by Paychex offers automated payroll at a lower starting price than most household specialists. It calculates pay and taxes, runs payroll on schedule, and handles filings, which suits families who want a straightforward tool without a premium price. Being part of Paychex also gives it scale and a long track record in payroll.

The weakness is specialization. A general payroll provider may not offer the same depth of household-specific guidance as Poppins, HomePay, or GTM, especially for state quirks or nanny share arrangements. Families with a simple, single-employee setup will likely be fine, while complex cases may need extra advice elsewhere.

Why it made the list
  • Lower starting price
  • Automated pay runs
  • Backed by a large payroll company
Keep in mind
  • Household expertise is less specialized than niche providers
  • Support style is more general
HomeWork Solutions logo
#5

HomeWork Solutions

Great for: Payroll plus tax support

Open homeworksolutions.com
Pricing starts atSee website
Free tierNo

HomeWork Solutions focuses on household employers and pairs payroll processing with tax support. It is often mentioned for families who want several payment options and a provider that understands household rules, not just small business payroll. The service covers the core tasks of pay calculation, tax handling, and year-end reporting.

Pricing transparency is the drawback, since starting prices are not always published in one clear figure online. Families should request a written quote that includes setup, monthly, and year-end fees before comparing it with flat-rate rivals. Once the full cost is clear, it can be a strong choice for families who want personal support.

Why it made the list
  • Household payroll and tax support
  • Multiple payment options
  • Long household focus
Keep in mind
  • Pricing is less transparent online
  • Quarterly billing may suit some budgets less well
Savvy Nanny Payroll logo
#6

Savvy Nanny Payroll

Great for: Budget-friendly payroll

Open savvynanny.com
Pricing starts at$39 per month
Free tierNo

Savvy Nanny Payroll appeals to budget-conscious families, with an entry price around $39 per month and, in some listings, coverage for two employees at that level. It handles the core payroll and tax tasks that most families need, without premium tiers or bundled HR services. For a straightforward nanny arrangement, that simplicity keeps costs down.

The caution is to verify coverage. Smaller providers can vary in how much state filing support they include, so ask for a written list of federal and state filings before you sign. If your state has extra requirements, confirm they are included in the quoted price. For simple cases, Savvy is a useful low-cost option.

Why it made the list
  • Low starting price
  • Covers two employees at the entry price in some listings
  • Simple setup
Keep in mind
  • Smaller provider with less name recognition
  • Check filing coverage in your state
Nest Payroll logo
#7

Nest Payroll

Great for: Back taxes and ongoing payroll

Open nestpayroll.com
Pricing starts at$42 per month
Free tierNo

Nest Payroll is often noted for helping families who need to sort out back taxes as well as run ongoing payroll. That matters, because many families only discover household employer duties after months of paying cash or informal checks. A provider that can clean up past periods and then keep future filings on track saves a second search.

The main limitation is scale and recognition. Nest is smaller than HomePay or GTM, so families should check reviews and confirm state coverage for their location. Pricing should also be confirmed in writing, since published figures change. For families with a cleanup need, Nest deserves a direct conversation.

Why it made the list
  • Helps with back tax cleanup
  • Ongoing payroll and filings
  • Clear focus on household employers
Keep in mind
  • Less well known than larger rivals
  • Confirm current pricing and state coverage
NannyPay logo
#8

NannyPay

Great for: Do-it-yourself tax calculation

Open nannypay.com
Pricing starts at$199.95 per year
Free tierFree trial

NannyPay takes a different approach from the full-service providers on this list. It is software that calculates wages, withholdings, and taxes, and prepares forms, but you handle the actual filing and payment yourself. That keeps the annual cost low, at about $199.95 per year for one to three employees in recent listings, and it suits hands-on employers.

The trade-off is clear. If you miss a deadline or file a form incorrectly, that risk stays with you, not with a service that guarantees filings. NannyPay is best for families who are organized, comfortable with tax forms, and want to save money in exchange for doing the final steps themselves.

Why it made the list
  • Low annual cost
  • Calculates federal and state taxes
  • Generates year-end forms for you to file
Keep in mind
  • You file and pay taxes yourself
  • No direct deposit filing service
  • Interface is basic

How we picked these

We compared official pricing pages, provider feature lists, and independent roundups of nanny payroll services, focusing on providers that still serve US household employers in 2026. We favored services that clearly cover payroll, tax withholding, quarterly filings, and year-end forms, or that clearly state when filing is left to the customer. Prices shown are starting prices where published, and we used See website where a provider does not publish a clear starting price.

What to ask before you sign up

First, ask exactly which filings are included. Confirm federal quarterly filings, state filings, new-hire reporting, and year-end forms such as the W-2 and Schedule H, and ask whether year-end preparation costs extra. A low monthly price can look different once setup and year-end fees are added.

Second, ask about your state. Household rules, unemployment taxes, sick leave, and overtime rules vary by state, and some providers charge extra for state registrations. Tell the provider your state, pay schedule, and whether you share a nanny, since each detail can change the quote.

Third, ask who pays if a filing is late or wrong. Full-service providers often guarantee on-time filings and cover penalties they cause, while do-it-yourself software leaves that duty with you. Get that promise in writing, and keep your own copies of pay stubs and filings even when a provider handles them.

Frequently asked questions

Do I need a payroll service to hire a nanny?

Not always, but hiring a nanny usually makes you a household employer with tax duties, including withholding, employer taxes, and year-end forms. A service reduces the risk of missed filings, while do-it-yourself software suits families who are comfortable handling forms themselves. This is general information only, not tax or legal advice.

What is Schedule H?

Schedule H is the form household employers file with their personal tax return to report household employment taxes. It summarizes wages paid, taxes withheld, and employer taxes owed for the year. Your payroll provider may prepare it for you, or you may need to complete it yourself, so confirm this before tax season.

How much does nanny payroll cost?

Recent listings put most full-service providers between about $39 and $75 per month for one employee, plus extra employee fees and possible year-end charges. Do-it-yourself software can cost about $200 per year, but you do the filing work. Always ask for the full annual cost, not just the monthly figure.

What happens in a nanny share?

Each family in a nanny share is usually treated as a separate employer, with its own payroll, tax filings, and W-2 for its share of wages. That means each family needs its own account or a clear arrangement with the provider. Tell the provider about the share before you sign up, since it affects pricing.

Can a payroll service fix back taxes?

Some providers, including Nest Payroll, offer help with back tax cleanup, while others focus only on current and future payroll. If you have unpaid periods, ask directly whether the provider handles prior filings and what that service costs. A tax professional can also help you assess penalties and payment options.

Sources

  1. https://www.poppinspayroll.com
  2. https://www.care.com/homepay
  3. https://www.gtm.com
  4. https://www.surepayroll.com
  5. https://www.homeworksolutions.com
  6. https://www.savvynanny.com
  7. https://www.nestpayroll.com
  8. https://www.nannypay.com
  9. https://www.techrepublic.com/article/best-nanny-payroll-services/
  10. https://fitsmallbusiness.com/best-nanny-payroll-service/

See where you really rank - block by block

ProMapRanker scans Google Maps across a grid of your service area. Simple monthly plans from $19, white-label on every plan.

Start free

Keep reading