ProMapRanker
🛠 Scheduled maintenance: We're performing scheduled maintenance on our scanning engine. New scans, audits and lookups are temporarily paused and will resume in approximately 12 hours. Your existing reports and dashboards remain fully available.
best payroll service for self employed

Best Payroll Service for Self Employed

Best Payroll Service for Self Employed
Gusto logo
Our #1Gusto

One-person S corporations and small teams · Pricing starts at: $49 per month

Open gusto.com
OnPay logo
Close secondOnPay
Visit
Patriot Software logo
Also solidPatriot Software
Visit

Key takeaways

  • This article is general information only, not tax or legal advice, and tax rules vary by state.
  • Service fees are separate from tax amounts, so a low subscription price does not mean low total cost.
  • Sole proprietors usually pay themselves by owner draw and may not need payroll at all, while S corporation owners often do.
  • Choose by whether you pay only yourself, contractors, employees, or a mix, and by how many states are involved.

Quick comparison

PickGreat forPricing starts atFree tier
GustoOne-person S corporations and small teams$49 per monthNoVisit
OnPaySimple full-service payroll$40 per monthNoVisit
Patriot SoftwareLowest base price$17 per monthNoVisit
QuickBooks PayrollQuickBooks Online users$45 per monthNoVisit
Square PayrollContractors and small teams$35 per monthNoVisit
SurePayrollSmall employers wanting simple payrollSee websiteNoVisit
Wave PayrollWave accounting usersSee websiteNoVisit

The best payroll service for self employed owners

We compared official feature pages, pricing pages, app store listings and public reviews. Every service below handles pay calculations, tax filings or contractor payments in some form, but the right choice depends on your business structure, your state and whether you pay employees, contractors or only yourself.

Gusto logo
#1

Gusto

Great for: One-person S corporations and small teams

Open gusto.com
Pricing starts at$49 per month
Free tierNo
Gusto website
gusto.com homepage

Gusto is our pick for most one-person S corporations because its Solo plan is built for that exact case. Solo costs 49 dollars a month plus 6 dollars per person, with compliant self-pay, automatic tax filing, S corporation compliance help and a reasonable salary calculator. That structure helps an owner pay a salary through payroll while keeping filings handled.

The limit is growth cost. Plus costs 80 dollars a month plus 12 dollars per person and adds multi-state payroll and next-day pay, while Premium costs 180 dollars plus 22 dollars per person. If you are a sole proprietor with no employees, you may not need payroll at all, since owner draws are not payroll, so check your structure before subscribing.

Why it made the list
  • Dedicated Solo plan for one-person S corporations
  • Automatic tax filings
  • Reasonable salary calculator
Keep in mind
  • Per-person fees add up as you hire
  • Multi-state payroll needs the higher Plus plan
OnPay logo
#2

OnPay

Great for: Simple full-service payroll

Open onpay.com
Pricing starts at$40 per month
Free tierNo
OnPay app screenshots
App Store screenshots

OnPay charges 40 dollars a month plus 6 dollars per person, with full-service payroll and tax filings included. That simple structure suits a self-employed owner who pays a few contractors or employees and wants predictable pricing without choosing between many tiers. It also works well if you start solo and later hire, since the same system scales to employees.

OnPay has fewer HR and benefits extras than Gusto or larger platforms, so a business that wants deep HR tools may need another system alongside it. For payroll itself, though, the clarity of one plan and one per-person price is a real strength.

Why it made the list
  • Simple flat pricing
  • Full-service tax filings
  • Good fit if you may hire later
Keep in mind
  • Fewer HR extras than larger rivals
  • Benefits options vary by state
Patriot Software logo
#3

Patriot Software

Great for: Lowest base price

Open patriotsoftware.com
Pricing starts at$17 per month
Free tierNo
Patriot Software app screenshots
App Store screenshots

Patriot Software offers the lowest base price in this list, with Basic payroll from 17 dollars a month plus 4 dollars per employee, and Full Service payroll from 37 dollars a month plus 4 dollars per employee. Basic suits an owner who wants help calculating pay but is comfortable handling tax filings, while Full Service adds tax filing and deposits.

The trade-off is clear: the cheapest plan requires more work from you. If you miss a filing deadline, penalties can quickly erase the saving, so only choose Basic if you are confident about state and federal filing duties and deadlines.

Why it made the list
  • Basic plan from 17 dollars a month plus 4 dollars per employee
  • Full-service option available
Keep in mind
  • Basic plan does not file taxes for you
  • Support and features are plainer than rivals
QuickBooks Payroll logo
#4

QuickBooks Payroll

Great for: QuickBooks Online users

Open quickbooks.intuit.com
Pricing starts at$45 per month
Free tierNo

QuickBooks Payroll Core costs 45 dollars a month plus 5 dollars per employee in published comparisons, with automatic tax filings and payroll linked directly to QuickBooks Online accounts. That link saves time on bookkeeping, since pay, tax and contractor costs flow into your accounts without manual entry.

If you do not already use QuickBooks Online, the combined cost is higher than a standalone payroll tool. It still suits accountants and owners who want one system for books and pay, but compare the total subscription cost, not only the payroll price.

Why it made the list
  • Tight link to QuickBooks accounting
  • Automatic tax filings on Core
  • Contractor payments included
Keep in mind
  • Needs a QuickBooks Online subscription for full value
  • Per-person fees add up
Square Payroll logo
#5

Square Payroll

Great for: Contractors and small teams

Open squareup.com
Pricing starts at$35 per month
Free tierNo

Square Payroll suits owners who mainly pay contractors, with a contractor-only plan and an employee plan from 35 dollars a month plus 6 dollars per employee in published comparisons. That makes it practical for a freelancer who hires subcontractors for projects, or a small shop with a few part-time staff.

Complex payroll needs, such as many states, shift differentials or union rules, may need a deeper system. Square works best when pay is straightforward, hours are simple, and you already use Square for payments or point of sale.

Why it made the list
  • Contractor-only option from 6 dollars per contractor
  • Employee plan from 35 dollars plus 6 dollars per person
Keep in mind
  • Less depth for complex multi-state payroll
  • Benefits vary by state
SurePayroll logo
#6

SurePayroll

Great for: Small employers wanting simple payroll

Open surepayroll.com
Pricing starts atSee website
Free tierNo

SurePayroll, part of Paychex, offers full-service payroll for small employers, with tax calculations, filings and direct deposit handled for you. That full-service model suits a self-employed owner who has hired one or two employees and wants filings taken off their plate, without learning a large enterprise system.

Pricing varies by plan and headcount, so request a quote for your exact setup before comparing it with flat-priced rivals. Also check state coverage and filing support for your state, since payroll tax rules and deadlines differ.

Why it made the list
  • Full-service payroll with tax filings
  • Simple setup for small teams
  • Mobile access
Keep in mind
  • Pricing is quoted by plan and headcount
  • Fewer integrations than larger rivals
Wave Payroll logo
#7

Wave Payroll

Great for: Wave accounting users

Open waveapps.com
Pricing starts atSee website
Free tierNo

Wave Payroll links payroll to Wave accounting, which helps owners who already invoice and track expenses in Wave. Published comparisons put Wave Payroll at 20 to 35 dollars a month plus 6 dollars per employee, depending on state, with tax filings included where available. That state variation matters, so confirm availability and price for your state first.

Wave Payroll is not available in every state, and its HR depth is limited compared with Gusto or OnPay. For a Wave user with simple payroll in a supported state, it is a convenient fit, but check state coverage before switching your books to Wave for payroll alone.

Why it made the list
  • Links to Wave accounting
  • Simple payroll for small teams
  • Contractor payments available
Keep in mind
  • Pricing varies by state
  • Payroll is not available in every state

How we picked these

We compared official feature pages, pricing pages, app store listings and public reviews. We kept services that support self-employed owners, sole proprietors with employees, S corporation owners, or contractor payments, and we kept service fees separate from tax amounts in every description. Where a price varied by state or headcount, we wrote See website or gave the published range.

Payroll service fees pay for calculation, payments and filings, not for the taxes themselves. Federal, state and local payroll taxes are amounts you owe on wages, and they are separate from the subscription price. Deadlines, rates and forms vary by state and by whether you pay employees or contractors, so confirm your duties with a tax professional or your state tax agency.

Also check worker classification carefully. Employees and independent contractors have different tax forms, W-2 versus 1099-NEC, and different rules. Misclassification can lead to back taxes and penalties, so do not choose a payroll tool to fix a classification question. Get advice on structure first, then choose the tool that fits that structure.

One more step before you subscribe: list every state where you have employees or contractors, and confirm the service files in each one. State registration, unemployment insurance and local tax rules differ, and a service that covers your home state may not cover a remote worker in another state. Also ask how corrections are handled if a pay run contains an error, since fixing a filed return is slower than fixing a draft. A short pre-subscription checklist of states, worker types and pay dates prevents most early payroll surprises.

Frequently asked questions

Do I need payroll if I am self-employed?

Not always. A sole proprietor or single-member LLC owner usually takes an owner draw, not a payroll salary, and reports income on a personal return. An S corporation owner who works in the business usually must pay a reasonable salary through payroll.

What is the difference between a service fee and a tax amount?

The service fee is what you pay the payroll company for its software and filing work. Tax amounts are the federal, state and local taxes owed on wages, which the service calculates and remits on your behalf, but which are not part of the subscription price.

Can payroll software handle contractors?

Yes, most services in this list handle contractor payments and year-end 1099 forms, often at a lower per-person price than employees. Check whether contractor payments include filing, and whether international contractors need an add-on.

Do payroll tax rules vary by state?

Yes, rates, registration, filing frequency and forms vary by state and sometimes by locality. A service that files in your state is essential, and you should still confirm registration and deadlines with your state agency.

Should I use payroll software or an accountant?

Many owners use both: software for regular runs and filings, and an accountant for year-end, structure and classification questions. If your pay is simple, software alone may suffice, but complex cases benefit from professional advice.

Sources

  1. https://gusto.com
  2. https://www.onpay.com
  3. https://www.patriotsoftware.com
  4. https://quickbooks.intuit.com
  5. https://squareup.com
  6. https://www.surepayroll.com
  7. https://www.waveapps.com

See where you really rank - block by block

ProMapRanker scans Google Maps across a grid of your service area. Simple monthly plans from $19, white-label on every plan.

Start free

Keep reading