How to Pick HR Software for Nonprofits

Nonprofits that want a PEO to offload benefits and HR liability · Pricing starts at: See website (per-employee pricing, custom quote)
Key takeaways
- Justworks takes the first slot, best suited to nonprofits that want a PEO to offload benefits and HR liability.
- Starting prices begin at $35/month + $12/employee/month with Rippling.
- Gusto fits nonprofits up to ~100 employees wanting payroll plus light HR at a published price.
- The main caution on BambooHR: no published pricing, so every quote comes through sales.
Direct answer
Our first pick is Justworks, best for nonprofits that want a PEO to offload benefits and HR liability. Alternatives: BambooHR for nonprofits that require a real HRIS for onboarding, PTO and performance, and Patriot Software for very small nonprofits with straightforward payroll and tight budgets. Details, prices and limits for the rest of the 6 tools are below.
Quick comparison
| Pick | Great for | Pricing starts at | Free tier | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Nonprofits that want a PEO to offload benefits and HR liability | See website (per-employee pricing, custom quote) | No | Visit | |
| Nonprofits that require a real HRIS for onboarding, PTO and performance | See website (custom quote only) | Free trial | Visit | |
| Very small nonprofits with straightforward payroll and tight budgets | $37/month + $5/worker premium/month (Full Service plan) | Free trial (30 days) | Visit | |
| Nonprofits with international staff, contractors or program workers abroad | $0 for Deel HR (free up to 200 employees); Contractor plans from $49/contractor/month | Yes | Visit | |
| Bigger nonprofits that want HR | $35/month + $12/employee/month (payroll starting point) | No | Visit | |
| Nonprofits up to ~100 employees | $49/month + $6/employee/month (Simple plan) | No | Visit |
Tool-by-tool breakdown
Choosing HR software for nonprofits usually comes down to price, fit and limits. This ProMapRanker guide sets 6 tools side by side on those three points, with the facts kept short and checkable.

Justworks
Great for: Nonprofits that want a PEO to offload benefits and HR liability

Choose Justworks for nonprofits that want a PEO to offload benefits and HR liability. Justworks is a PEO, which means it becomes the employer of record for tax and benefits purposes whereas your nonprofit keeps day-to-day control of the work. That structure hands a small nonprofit access to large-group health plans, workers compensation and HR compliance support it could never negotiate alone.
The trade-offs are cost and control. On top of that, PEO pricing is per employee a month and Justworks quotes it through sales, so budget planning starts with a conversation instead of a pricing page. As for the details, payroll, benefits administration, time tracking and HR tools come in one package, with 24/7 support. Check the vendor site for Justworks pricing; none is listed in this comparison. Justworks has no permanent free option.
Where it is weaker: Per-employee pricing quoted through sales, so budgeting starts with a call.
- Benefits admin
- PEO structure provides a small nonprofit access to large-group health plans
- The PEO sets certain processes and timelines, so you provide up some control

BambooHR
Great for: Nonprofits that require a real HRIS for onboarding, PTO and performance

Pick BambooHR if this describes you: nonprofits that require a real HRIS for onboarding, PTO and performance. BambooHR is the HRIS pick: the tool you buy when onboarding, PTO policies, performance reviews and a proper employee database matter more than payroll itself.
As for the details, buy BambooHR for HR depth, not for cheap payroll. The trade is price opacity. No starting price is listed for BambooHR here; confirm pricing on the vendor site. Free access: Free trial.
Where it shines: Reporting a board can understand. Trade-offs to know: Payroll is an add-on instead of the core product.
- Time-off workflows and performance management
- Capable integrations with payroll providers
- No published pricing, so every quote comes through sales

Patriot Software
Great for: Very small nonprofits with straightforward payroll and tight budgets

In short, Patriot Software is for very small nonprofits with straightforward payroll and tight budgets. Patriot is the budget pick. For anything beyond payroll, pair it with something else.
The clever part for cash-strapped organizations: you are billed only for workers premium each month, so grant gaps and seasonal dips do not inflate the bill. Each extra state costs $12 a month, and standard direct deposit takes four days. What you pay to start with Patriot Software: $37/month + $5/worker premium/month. On free options: Free trial (30 days).
Upsides: Billed only for workers actually premium each month, so quiet months cost just the base fee.
Points against: performance tracking or benefits admin; Payroll only, with no onboarding suite.
- State and local filings plus year-end forms
- Full Service spans federal
- Standard direct deposit takes four days

Deel
Great for: Nonprofits with international staff, contractors or program workers abroad
For nonprofits with international staff, contractors or program workers abroad, Deel is a natural candidate. The product's strength is global compliance, not cheap local payroll. Use Deel HR free for your people records and look elsewhere for domestic payroll, or buy Deel when your team crosses borders.
From a buyer's view, Deel HR, its core HRIS, is free for up to 200 employees, which makes it the cheapest credible employee database available. Beyond that, for a purely domestic nonprofit, Deel is the wrong tool. Deel cost at the entry level: $0 for Deel HR. Deel offers a free plan.
Where it falls short: US payroll runs through the EOR product at a per-employee price far above domestic choices.
- Credible HRIS for up to 200 employees
- Deel HR is a free
- Overkill for a purely domestic nonprofit
Choose Rippling for bigger nonprofits that want HR, payroll, IT and benefits on one employee record. For organizations with real operational complexity, that consolidation replaces multiple separate subscriptions and the manual work between them.
Points against: Modular pricing stacks on top of core product fees.
In practice, the pricing stacks. Rippling makes sense when complexity is the problem; for a 15-person charity it is overkill. Price to start with Rippling: $35/month + $12/employee/month. Rippling has no permanent free option.
- One employee record drives HR, payroll, benefits
- Replaces three or four separate tools
- Sales-led quotes and heavier implementation than the self-serve tools here
Gusto is aimed squarely at nonprofits up to ~100 employees wanting payroll plus light HR at a published price. The Simple plan costs $49 a month plus $6 per employee, bundles full-service tax filing with W-2s and 1099s, and spans onboarding, offer letters, PTO tracking and a straightforward hiring flow. There is no fund accounting, no volunteer management and no grant reporting, and time tracking plus next-day direct deposit sit on the Plus level at $80 plus $12 per employee.
The main drawbacks: next-day direct deposit and multi-state payroll sit on Plus, not Simple.
Worth adding: the honest catch is that Gusto was made for companies, so nothing here speaks nonprofit. On top of that, for payroll plus light HR at a published price, it is hard to beat. For deeper HR work, look at BambooHR. Integrations with QuickBooks and Xero keep the finance side clean, and month-to-month billing means no annual contract to justify to the board. On cost, Gusto starts like this: $49/month + $6/employee/month. Gusto has no permanent free option.
- Published pricing with no contracts and free setup
- Unlimited payroll runs with full-service tax filing and W-2/1099 generation on every plan
- Time tracking
Selection criteria
ProMapRanker looked at what each vendor publishes: pricing, plan limits, feature coverage for HR software for nonprofits and stated drawbacks. No hands-on testing is claimed. Where a price is missing, the vendor does not list one publicly or ties it to a quote. Always confirm before budgeting. The ranking is editorial: typical fit first, then clear pricing, then free access. If your needs are unusual, read the profiles rather than relying on position.
Pre-purchase checklist
- Ask Justworks and BambooHR for a written quote, since no starting price is shown.
- Test the free plan from Deel against your real workload before relying on it.
- Use real work to test the free trial from BambooHR and Patriot Software, rather than a demo project.
- Before choosing Justworks, weigh its main limit: per-employee pricing quoted through sales, so budgeting starts with a call.
- Read the plan comparison for Patriot Software carefully; key features often start on a higher tier.
- Work out what Rippling costs with your real seat count, add-ons and usage, not just the entry price.
Frequently asked questions
Which options for HR software for nonprofits have a free plan?
Deel is the only tool in this list with a free plan. Free plans usually cap users, projects or features, so check the limits on the vendor page. Several others offer a trial instead.
Is Justworks the right pick for everyone comparing HR software for nonprofits?
No single tool suits every team. Justworks comes first because it fits nonprofits that want a PEO to offload benefits and HR liability, while BambooHR suits nonprofits that need a real HRIS for onboarding, PTO and performance and Patriot Software suits very small nonprofits with straightforward payroll and tight budgets. Match the tool to your own size, budget and workflow before deciding.
Can HR software track volunteers?
Use dedicated volunteer management software for scheduling and hour tracking, and keep the HR system for premium staff only. Patriot's pay-only-for-workers-premium billing is the closest fit if the line ever blurs.
Can I try these tools before paying?
Often, yes. Deel has a free plan and BambooHR and Patriot Software offer a free trial. Use your own data and a real task during the test, and check what the free tier or trial limits before you rely on it.
What is the cheapest option for HR software for nonprofits in this list?
On published monthly entry prices, Rippling is the lowest here at $35/month + $12/employee/month. Entry price is only part of the cost, because seats, add-ons and billing terms can change the total.
Sources
See where you really rank - block by block
ProMapRanker scans Google Maps across a grid of your service area. Simple monthly plans from $19, white-label on every plan.
Start free
