Shortlist

Phishing simulation plus automatic remediation · Pricing starts at: See website
Direct answer
For phishing simulation plus automatic remediation, IRONSCALES is where this list starts. Alternatives: Barracuda Email Protection for multi-layer protection with backup, and Microsoft Defender for Office 365 for Microsoft 365 shops adding phishing defense. The other 3 tools in the list cover narrower or pricier cases.
Key takeaways
- IRONSCALES is the opening pick, best for phishing simulation plus automatic remediation.
- Neither IRONSCALES nor Coro, nor any of the other 4 tools, has a permanent free plan; trials and quotes are the norm.
- Starting prices begin at $2.00 per user/month with Microsoft Defender for Office 365.
- What to know about Barracuda Email Protection first: pricing on request with three tiers to decode.
- Coro suits SMBs consolidating security tools.
Quick comparison
| Pick | Great for | Pricing starts at | Free tier | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Phishing simulation plus automatic remediation | See website | Free trial | Visit | |
| Multi-layer protection with backup | See website | Free trial | Visit | |
| Microsoft 365 shops adding phishing defense | $2.00 per user/month (premium yearly, Plan 1) | Free trial | Visit | |
| SMBs wanting enterprise-grade defense | See website | Free trial | Visit | |
| Budget-conscious secure email gateway | See website | Free trial | Visit | |
| SMBs consolidating security tools | $9.50 per user/month (Essentials Suite) | Free trial | Visit |
Email Security Software profiles
ProMapRanker compared 6 tools for email security software. The goal is a practical shortlist: published prices, free plan facts, best-fit use cases and honest limits for every entry.

IRONSCALES serves phishing simulation plus automatic remediation. IRONSCALES pairs automatic phishing defense with the human layer. Its system spots and remediates phishing messages in employee inboxes, and its phishing simulation module trains the same employees to report what slips through.
As for the details, suspected messages get quarantined and investigated with minimal admin clicks. The reporting button in Outlook turns every employee into a sensor. The product also assumes Microsoft 365 or Google Workspace; it is not a generic gateway for on-premises mail servers. Run the trial with your actual phishing simulation list to see whether the training content suits your workforce before negotiating. In daily use, when one customer reports a phishing email, that intelligence feeds detection for everyone else on the product. No starting price is listed for IRONSCALES here; confirm pricing on the vendor site. Free options: Free trial.
Where it is weaker: Quote-only pricing.
- Crowd-sourced threat sharing across customers
- Phishing simulation built in
- Interface can feel busy for first-time admins

For multi-layer protection with backup, Barracuda Email Protection is a natural candidate. For Microsoft 365 shops, the backup piece is worth pricing out separately. In practice, losing a mailbox to ransomware with no backup is a different disaster.
Watch-outs: Pricing on request with three levels to decode.
On top of that, negotiate the level based on the features you will actually use, since the higher plans add capability numerous small teams never touch. What separates Barracuda from single-purpose gateways is the bundle. Check the vendor site for Barracuda Email Protection pricing; none is listed in this comparison. Trial and free access: Free trial.
- Cloud backup and archiving available
- AI-based phishing and impersonation defense
- Account takeover features need the higher plan

Microsoft Defender for Office 365
Great for: Microsoft 365 shops adding phishing defense

Pick Microsoft Defender for Office 365 if this describes you: Microsoft 365 shops adding phishing defense. If your company already lives in Microsoft 365, Defender for Office 365 is the path of least resistance. On top of that, plan 1 costs $2 per user a month on an annual commitment and layers on Safe Links, Safe Attachments, and anti-phishing policies straight inside Exchange Online.
Drawbacks to consider: Tied to the Microsoft ecosystem.
Beyond that, plan 1 includes the essentials: link rewriting with time-of-click checks, attachment detonation, and impersonation protection. Plan 2 at $5 per user a month layers on automatic investigation and response, threat hunting tools, and attack simulation training. For a company with an IT generalist instead of a security analyst, Plan 1 is normally the sweet spot. It also will not help with email continuity if Microsoft itself has an outage. On cost, Microsoft Defender for Office 365 starts like this: $2.00 per user/month. On free options: Free trial.
- Safe Links and Safe Attachments included
- Nothing to route or install
- Plan 2 features cost more than double
Think of Proofpoint Essentials for SMBs wanting enterprise-grade defense. Pricing is the real friction point. URLs get rewritten and checked when the recipient clicks, not just when the message arrives, which catches pages that only turn malicious hours after delivery.
The main drawbacks: Final price typically set by a reseller, not published.
Essentials packages URL Defense, attachment sandboxing, and BEC controls into an admin console that does not need a security engineer to operate. Also, Proofpoint Essentials exists for the same reason Proofpoint sells to half the Fortune 100: phishing is a volume business and the same threat intel guards a 40-person law firm plus it protects a bank. More specifically, expect it to land above budget gateways like SpamTitan but below a full enterprise Proofpoint bundle. They typically get better pricing than a direct call. This comparison lists no price for Proofpoint Essentials; ask the vendor. Trial and free access: Free trial.
- BEC detection tuned for smaller teams
- Simplified admin controls
- Link rewriting can annoy users
SpamTitan targets budget-conscious secure email gateway. Attachments get detonated in a Bitdefender-powered sandbox, and there is dedicated CEO impersonation protection, which is the exact attack that empties small business bank accounts. SpamTitan is the value pick in this category and has been for years.
It is a traditional secure email gateway: mail routes through SpamTitan's filters first, which strip spam, phishing, and malware before anything reaches the inbox. Setup is genuinely quick, and it can run in the cloud or on your own hardware if you need data to stay local. Also note that alias addresses can count as separate users in licensing, so check how your domain's addresses map to the seat count. No starting price is listed for SpamTitan here; confirm pricing on the vendor site. Free access: Free trial.
Drawbacks to consider: Occasional false positives need admin tuning.
- Quick cloud deployment
- Bitdefender-powered attachment sandboxing
- Reporting is entry-level compared with premium tools
Coro is built with SMBs consolidating security tools in mind. Coro is not really an email security product. It is an entire security department sold as software, and email protection is one module inside it.
That positioning is exactly why small companies buy it. Rather than a gateway vendor, an endpoint vendor, and a backup vendor, you get one console, one agent, and one invoice. The email module manages phishing and malware detection for Microsoft 365 and Google Workspace, with automatic remediation that pulls malicious messages out of inboxes without an admin clicking anything. What you pay to start with Coro: $9.50 per user/month. Trial and free access: Free trial.
Main advantages: One bill spans email. Trade-offs to know: Email module cannot be bought alone cheaply.
- Straightforward admin console
- Automatic remediation
- Less granular email controls than gateway specialists
What went into this list
Pricing pages, product documentation and feature lists were the main sources, and every entry carries at least one honest drawback. Treat prices as a snapshot: vendors change plans often, so check the vendor site for the figure that applies today. The ranking is editorial: typical fit first, then clear pricing, then free access. If your needs are unusual, read the profiles rather than relying on position.
What to check before you buy
- Ask IRONSCALES, Barracuda Email Protection, Proofpoint Essentials and SpamTitan for a written quote, since no starting price is shown.
- Take the trial from IRONSCALES, Barracuda Email Protection, Microsoft Defender for Office 365 and others and push a live task through it before you pay.
- Before choosing IRONSCALES, weigh its main limit: quote-only pricing.
- Let daily users try Microsoft Defender for Office 365 on real work; their feedback beats any feature checklist.
- List the apps you already depend on and check that Coro supports each one on the plan you would buy.
Frequently asked questions
Can email security software stop business email compromise?
No product stops every BEC attempt, so pair the software with a verification rule that any changed payment details get confirmed by phone.
What is the cheapest option for email security software in this list?
On published monthly entry prices, Microsoft Defender for Office 365 is the lowest here at $2.00 per user/month. Entry price is only part of the cost, because seats, add-ons and billing terms can change the total.
Can I try these options before paying?
Often, yes. IRONSCALES, Barracuda Email Protection, Microsoft Defender for Office 365 and others offer a free trial. Use your own data and a real task during the test, and check what the free tier or trial limits before you rely on it.
Will email security software slow down email delivery?
Modern cloud gateways add seconds, not minutes, to delivery for most messages. If your business relies on instant delivery for time-sensitive messages, test with your real mail flow during the trial and check the vendor's SLA for delivery times.
Do these tools publish their prices?
Not all of them. IRONSCALES, Barracuda Email Protection, Proofpoint Essentials and SpamTitan publish no starting price, so expect a quote request for those. The rest, Microsoft Defender for Office 365 included, show a starting price, though seats and billing terms still change the final cost.
Is a free trial enough to evaluate an email security tool?
Make sure the trial bundles the level you would actually buy, since some vendors trial the premium plan and quote you the standard one. Get the quoted price in writing before the trial ends so the renewal number is not a surprise.
Sources
See where you really rank - block by block
ProMapRanker scans Google Maps across a grid of your service area. Simple monthly plans from $19, white-label on every plan.
Start free


