Best and Worst Home Warranty Companies in 2026

older homes and high system caps · Pricing starts at: See website
Key takeaways
- American Home Shield offers the highest system caps here and rare cover for unknown pre-existing conditions.
- Liberty Home Guard and First American stand out for contractor flexibility and appliance limits.
- Choice Home Warranty and Select Home Warranty carry the weakest records in this list and need the most caution.
- Every plan has per item caps and a service fee per claim, so the monthly price alone never tells the full cost.
Quick comparison
| Pick | Great for | Pricing starts at | Free tier | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| older homes and high system caps | See website | No | Visit | |
| flexible plans in all 50 states | See website | No | Visit | |
| high appliance limits | See website | No | Visit | |
| lifetime workmanship guarantee | See website | No | Visit | |
| appliance cover on a budget | See website | No | Visit | |
| newer homes and builder cover | See website | No | Visit | |
| broad item lists | See website | No | Visit | |
| low monthly price only | See website | No | Visit | |
| buyers who accept strict caps | See website | No | Visit |
The best and worst home warranty companies
A home warranty is a service contract, not home insurance, and the difference shows up at claim time. We compared official plan pages, sample contracts, published caps and service fees, and public complaint patterns to separate strong performers from weak ones. This is general information only, not financial advice. Coverage, exclusions, and prices depend on your home, location, and plan, and no price or payout is guaranteed.

For many readers, American Home Shield is the first name worth checking because it fits older homes and high system caps. American Home Shield sells three plans, ShieldSilver for systems, ShieldGold for systems and appliances, and ShieldPlatinum for broader cover including roof leaks. Its published system caps are among the highest in this comparison. The strength is protection for older homes, since cover for unknown pre-existing conditions and damage from rust, corrosion, and sediment is rare in this market. That combination is why we kept it on this list, even though no option here is right for every reader. The weakness is price and rigidity, because the top plan costs more than many rivals and buyers cannot buy an appliance only plan. Before you commit, check the current terms on the official site and confirm availability for your state, country, or use case. If that weakness touches the one thing you need most, move on to the next name on this list rather than trying to work around it.
- Covers unknown pre-existing conditions
- High system caps
- Roof leak cover on top plan
- Higher monthly cost than rivals
- No appliance only plan
- Only a small set of add-ons

Liberty Home Guard earns its place here for readers who need flexible plans in all 50 states. Liberty Home Guard sells appliance, systems, and combined plans, with service fees that can start lower than the flat fees charged by several rivals. It is also one of the few large providers that lets customers use their own technician in some situations, subject to approval. The strength is flexibility, since buyers can match the plan to appliances, systems, or both without paying for cover they do not need. That combination is why we kept it on this list, even though no option here is right for every reader. The weakness is the per item cap, because a 2,000 dollar limit can leave a large gap on a major appliance or system replacement. Before you commit, check the current terms on the official site and confirm availability for your state, country, or use case. If that weakness touches the one thing you need most, move on to the next name on this list rather than trying to work around it.
- Sold in all 50 states
- Own technician option in some cases
- Clear plan tiers
- Per item limit of 2,000 dollars on many items
- BBB rating has drawn criticism
- Service fee varies

When high appliance limits is the priority, First American Home Warranty deserves a close look. First American Home Warranty offers combined plans with strong appliance limits and a long history in real estate transactions. The strength is the appliance limit, which matters when a high end refrigerator, oven, or laundry set fails and replacement costs run well above a typical cap. That combination is why we kept it on this list, even though no option here is right for every reader. The weakness is cost, because quoted monthly prices often sit above budget rivals, and the service fee still applies on each approved claim. Before you commit, check the current terms on the official site and confirm availability for your state, country, or use case. If that weakness touches the one thing you need most, move on to the next name on this list rather than trying to work around it.
- High per appliance limits
- Long operating history
- Broad combined plans
- Higher monthly prices in many quotes
- Availability is limited in some states
- Service fee per claim
AFC Home Warranty stands out in this group for lifetime workmanship guarantee. AFC Home Warranty, also shown as AFC Home Club in some listings, sells appliance and combined plans with a lifetime workmanship guarantee on covered repairs in its published terms. The strength is repeat repair protection, since a fix that fails again should not mean paying a second service fee for the same fault under the guarantee terms. That combination is why we kept it on this list, even though no option here is right for every reader. The weakness is availability, because AFC is not sold in California, Hawaii, and Washington, so readers in those states need a different provider. Before you commit, check the current terms on the official site and confirm availability for your state, country, or use case. If that weakness touches the one thing you need most, move on to the next name on this list rather than trying to work around it.
- Lifetime guarantee on labour in some plans
- Several plan tiers
- Appliance and combined options
- Not sold in every state
- Per item caps apply
- Pricing varies by location
Readers who want appliance cover on a budget will find Cinch Home Services a practical starting point. Cinch Home Services sells combined plans with add-ons for items such as pools, spas, wells, and outside lines. The strength is entry cost, since buyers who mainly want appliance cover can start lower than with a top tier combined plan elsewhere. That combination is why we kept it on this list, even though no option here is right for every reader. The weakness is consistency, because public reviews include delayed scheduling and uneven contractor communication, so the low price can come with a slower claim experience. Before you commit, check the current terms on the official site and confirm availability for your state, country, or use case. If that weakness touches the one thing you need most, move on to the next name on this list rather than trying to work around it.
- Lower entry prices in many quotes
- Appliance and combined plans
- Add-ons for pools and wells
- Per term caps apply
- Contractor scheduling complaints appear in reviews
- Service fee up to 150 dollars
2-10 Home Buyers Warranty is a strong match when newer homes and builder cover matters most. 2-10 Home Buyers Warranty began in builder warranty work and now sells systems and combined home warranty plans to homeowners and buyers. The strength is builder and systems experience, which suits buyers who want a provider used to working with newer systems and home sale transactions. That combination is why we kept it on this list, even though no option here is right for every reader. The weakness is that headline pricing is quote based, so readers cannot compare a firm monthly figure without entering home details first. Before you commit, check the current terms on the official site and confirm availability for your state, country, or use case. If that weakness touches the one thing you need most, move on to the next name on this list rather than trying to work around it.
- Builder backed history
- Systems and combined plans
- Roof leak options on some plans
- Pricing needs a quote
- Caps vary by plan
- Less appliance only choice
If broad item lists is what you are shopping for, Old Republic Home Protection belongs on the shortlist. Old Republic Home Protection sells plans with a wide list of covered items and a choice of service fee levels in many states. The strength is breadth, since the covered item list is longer than many budget plans, which reduces the chance of a surprise exclusion on a common system. That combination is why we kept it on this list, even though no option here is right for every reader. The weakness is that breadth does not remove caps, and buyers still need to read per item limits before assuming a full replacement is covered. Before you commit, check the current terms on the official site and confirm availability for your state, country, or use case. If that weakness touches the one thing you need most, move on to the next name on this list rather than trying to work around it.
- Wide list of covered items
- Service fee choices
- Long market presence
- Monthly prices sit mid to high
- Caps vary by item
- Availability varies by state
Choice Home Warranty takes a different route to low monthly price only, and that difference is the point. Choice Home Warranty sells two combined plans at monthly prices that often undercut larger rivals. The strength, narrowly, is monthly price, since budget buyers can get combined systems and appliance cover for less than with several rivals. That combination is why we kept it on this list, even though no option here is right for every reader. The weakness is trust, because Choice agreed an 11.8 million dollar settlement with the Arizona Attorney General in early 2026 over allegations it misled customers about what contracts covered, and public reviews still report claim disputes. We place it among the weak performers here. Before you commit, check the current terms on the official site and confirm availability for your state, country, or use case. If that weakness touches the one thing you need most, move on to the next name on this list rather than trying to work around it.
- Low monthly prices in many quotes
- Combined plans
- Wide item list on paper
- 2026 Arizona settlement over coverage claims
- Claim denial complaints in public reviews
- 3,000 dollar per item cap
Among the names here, Select Home Warranty is the one to study for buyers who accept strict caps. Select Home Warranty sells appliance, systems, and combined plans with a long add-on list. Its entry prices can look attractive, especially for appliance only buyers. The strength is plan choice at a low entry price, since buyers can pick a narrow plan instead of a full combined plan. That combination is why we kept it on this list, even though no option here is right for every reader. The weakness is payout depth, because published comparisons show appliance caps as low as 500 dollars on some plans, which barely covers a major appliance repair. We place it among the weak performers here. Before you commit, check the current terms on the official site and confirm availability for your state, country, or use case. If that weakness touches the one thing you need most, move on to the next name on this list rather than trying to work around it.
- Lower entry prices in some quotes
- Appliance, systems, and combined plans
- Many add-ons
- Low appliance caps in published comparisons
- Service fee up to 200 dollars
- Claim limit complaints
How we picked these
We compared official plan pages, published caps and service fees, sample contract terms, and public reviews and complaint patterns. We kept providers with live nationwide or near nationwide plans in October 2026, and we weighted cap depth, pre-existing condition rules, contractor choice, and complaint history over monthly price alone. We did not claim hands-on testing.
Which ones to avoid, and how to buy well
Avoid signing with Choice Home Warranty or Select Home Warranty without reading the full sample contract and checking current complaint patterns in your state. Choice carries the 2026 Arizona settlement and a pattern of coverage disputes, while Select carries low appliance caps that can make a claim worth far less than the repair bill. Also avoid any home warranty seller that will not publish pricing, caps, and a sample contract before you pay, since hidden terms are a warning sign in this market. Buy on total cost, not monthly price alone. Add the annual premium, the service fee multiplied by the number of claims you expect, and any gap between the cap and a realistic replacement cost. Check the waiting period, which is often 30 days, and check whether roof leaks, plumbing, and HVAC items you actually own are included or sold as add-ons. Get the quote in writing, confirm the service fee and caps for your ZIP code, and keep the contract. This article is general information only, not financial advice, and coverage, exclusions, and prices depend on your home, location, and plan, with no guaranteed price or payout.
Frequently asked questions
What does a home warranty cover?
A home warranty covers repair or replacement of named home systems and appliances that break from normal wear, subject to caps and exclusions. It does not replace home insurance, which covers damage from events such as fire, storm, or theft.
What is a service fee?
A service fee, also called a trade call fee, is paid per claim visit, often from 65 to 150 dollars depending on the provider and plan. It applies even when a repair is approved, so frequent small claims can cost more than the premium saving.
Are pre-existing conditions covered?
Most providers exclude known pre-existing conditions, and American Home Shield is unusual in covering unknown pre-existing conditions.
Why are Choice and Select rated weak here?
Choice carries a 2026 Arizona settlement over coverage claims and a pattern of claim disputes in public reviews, while Select carries low appliance caps in published comparisons. Both can still sell a low priced plan, but both need far more contract reading than the stronger names here.
How long is the waiting period?
Most plans impose a waiting period of about 30 days after purchase before claims can be filed, though plans bought with a home sale often start at closing. Confirm the exact waiting period in writing before you pay.
Is a home warranty worth it for a new home?
A new home often has builder and manufacturer warranties that already cover many items, so a home warranty may duplicate cover in the first years. It tends to make more sense for older homes where systems and appliances are past manufacturer cover.
Sources
See where you really rank - block by block
ProMapRanker scans Google Maps across a grid of your service area. Simple monthly plans from $19, white-label on every plan.
Start free






